Welcome to Cristy’s Pizza
At Cristy’s Pizza, we believe in crafting a community-centered dining experience. Located in the heart of Circleville, Ohio, our story unfolds around a passion for exceptional pizza, offering a wide range of delicious options that cater to all tastes, including enticing vegetarian dishes. With our welcoming atmosphere and amenities such as outdoor seating and wheelchair accessibility, we are committed to creating a family-friendly environment. Whether you’re savoring a slice with friends during Happy Hour or enjoying our convenient delivery service, Cristy’s Pizza is more than just a place to eat; it's a destination where flavors and community connect.
- 1029 S Court St Circleville, OH 43113 United States Hotline: (740) 420-9191
If you're a pizza aficionado looking for a slice of joy, look no further than Cristy’s Pizza, located at 1029 S Court St in Circleville, Ohio. This bustling eatery has been delighting locals and visitors alike with its mouthwatering pies and vibrant dining atmosphere.
Cristy’s Pizza offers a wide selection, catering to a variety of tastes. Whether you're a meat lover or a vegetarian, you'll find something that tickles your palate. The menu is diverse yet focused, ensuring that every dish is crafted with care and a touch of creativity.
- Delivery and Takeout: Perfect for those nights when you crave pizza but want to relax at home.
- Reservations: Make sure you don’t miss out on a table during busy hours.
- Happy Hour Specials: Enjoy exceptional deals that make your dining experience even sweeter.
- Private Dining: Ideal for family gatherings or corporate events that call for some delicious pizza.
- Outdoor Seating: With heated and covered options available, you can enjoy your meal al fresco, no matter the weather.
- Family-Friendly Environment: Cristy’s Pizza is a fantastic spot for kids, complete with friendly waitstaff and a welcoming atmosphere.
For the tech-savvy patrons, Cristy’s Pizza accepts various payment methods, including credit cards, Android Pay, and Apple Pay — making payment as easy as pie! While you savor your meal, enjoy the ambiance complemented by a TV, ideal for catching up on sports or local events.
One of the standout features of Cristy’s Pizza is its commitment to accommodating all diners, including those with mobility challenges, thanks to wheelchair accessibility. Whether you're stopping by for a quick lunch or planning an evening out with family and friends, this establishment ticks all the right boxes.
In summary, Cristy’s Pizza is more than just a pizzeria; it's a culinary destination that promises memorable meals, delightful service, and a welcoming vibe. So, if you're in the Circleville area, don't miss your chance to indulge in the flavors of Cristy’s Pizza — your taste buds will thank you!
For more information or to place an order, give them a call at (740) 420-9191 and prepare to embark on a pizza adventure.

Carried out on our way through Circleville. Ordered half cheese-half pepperoni, green pepper and onion pie. Crispy crust around the edge, soft in the middle. LOTS of cheese (did not order extra), mild sauce and plenty of toppings. Piping hot and very delicious! Offered plates and napkins...very handy for the balance of our trip. Just off Rt 23 so easy access. Will pick up again when in the area.

Passing through on our road trip from Michigan to NC, Circleville is just about the halfway point. We were so pleasantly surprised to find Cristy's Pizza near the hotel and with such great service. We didn't realize it was not an eat in restaurant, but we waited a short while in our car and the staff brought it out to us. We had one small sausage pizza and another small veggie pizza on cauliflower crust. Both were so yummy. Cauliflower crust was so crispy and the veggies were plentiful. They put the right amount of sauce on their pizzas and the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. It was definitely our favorite meal on the road during this trip!

Good pizza that is consistent regardless of when you order and the loyalty rewards are worth being a regular customer

While their pizza is good, I don't come here for their actual pizza. I come for their subs. Specifically the pizza and ham & cheese subs. I really like that their salads use romaine lettuce that is actually green whereas a lot of other places use iceberg. Their service is great, always fast & friendly.

like their pizza a lot, I love their sweet sauce. Definitely worth a try. I like their pizza nibblers too, soooo good! Try them! We had pepperoni nibblers and loved them. A little greasy but that's okay. Tasty! Their subs are pretty good too, had their Italian sub I think. We enjoyed it all and recommend this to anybody craving pizza!

The best pizza in Circleville & even after ordering once a week for dinner I'm still in love with the fresh quality ingredients

My family and I moved to the area in the fall and just got around to trying Christy's a couple weeks ago. I wish we'd tried it sooner. Love the chewy crust and the slightly sweet sauce. Love their giant pepperonis! There was the tiniest problem with our first order, which I mentioned on their website, and the next day the store manager (I think his name was Josh? Super nice guy!) called and wanted to make it right. The service has been outstanding the 3 times now that we've ordered. They even made this Eastern Ohio girl's day by baking one for me and putting the cheese on after. Its now our official pizza place. Definitely recommend. Try the Goliath!